Trump Politicizes Hurricane Tragedy in Puerto Rico

Puerto Rico needs help and hope not presidential politics. /Government of Puerto Rico

In a series of tweets, President Donald Trump has politicized the hurricane tragedy in Puerto Rico, where 3.4 million Puerto Ricans are desperately coping without water, electricity, work, cash, low food supplies and much more.

When Harvey flooded Houston, Trump didn’t tweet about the city’s lack of zoning codes and its growth-at-all-cost plan to pave over its plains, which caused huge water runoff and flooding. It was not the moment to blame the flood victims, who had lost nearly everything, for their leaders’ poor political decisions. Indeed, Trump has visited Texas twice since Harvey struck the state.

When Irma smashed into Florida, Trump didn’t tweet about how the dismantling of growth management and other protections over eight years has opened up the state for disaster. Or how the weakening of nursing home rules in a state with the highest population of elderly in the nation may have led to the deaths of 11 people in a South Florida nursing home whose license should have been yanked years ago.

Morally Bankrupt

Now comes Puerto Rico, with the worse hurricane disaster in the modern history of the United States, and instead of sending more water, food and aid, Trump blames the victims for the poor political decisions of their leaders, tweeting on Monday:

Texas & Florida are doing great but Puerto Rico, which was already suffering from broken infrastructure & massive debt, is in deep trouble…It’s old electrical grid, which was in terrible shape, was devastated. Much of the Island was destroyed, with billions of dollars…….owed to Wall Street and the banks which, sadly, must be dealt with. Food, water and medical are top priorities – and doing well.

This right here is the morally bankrupt equivalent of former President George W. Bush’s words to former FEMA chief Michael Brown for a job well done – not! – shortly after Hurricane Katrina hit Louisiana, Alabama and Mississippi in 2005. “Brownie, you’re doin’ a heckuva a job.”

“Brownie” ended up resigning from FEMA when the images of unattended needs and massive suffering during and post Katrina were plastered all over television and newspapers.

Puerto Rico Not Doing Well

Mr. President, Puerto Rico is not doing well. Hurricane María is way bigger than Katrina. More aid is needed. Where is the water, food, fuel, electricity? Even Gov. Ricardo Rosselló is complaining about the response.

He is asking for Defense Department help for more search-and-rescue missions. In other words, a week after Hurricane María made landfall people are still missing. About 24 of 78 municipalities have not been declared federal disaster areas. Cell communication is down in 92 percent of the island, per the Federal Communications Commission. The gas pumps are still dry. It’s unlikely Puerto Rico can repay FEMA aid.

Do Your Job

There will come a day when we can tackle the issues of poor zoning and construction in Houston,  weakened regulations in Florida and poor infrastructure and high debt in Puerto Rico. But this is not that day.

Do your job. Tend to the needs of the men, women and children drowning in this tragedy in Puerto Rico – or get the heck out the way.

˜˜Maria Padilla,  Editor

Reinventing Puerto Rico after Hurricane María

Puerto Rico faces years of rebuilding and reinventing itself to get its economy and people moving again. /Government of Puerto Rico

Reinventing Puerto Rico after Hurricane María won’t be a quick fix. Puerto Rico is flattened – no water, electricity and communications with the outside world. It faces billions of dollars in uninsured damages from two hurricanes. The people are exhausted, possibly depressed, by the lack of resources.

The governor and his administration warn that the island may be without power up to four months, difficult for an already battered population to swallow – coming on top of a very long economic decline, loss of sovereignty, bankruptcy and now two hurricanes to top off the destruction.

After Hurricane María

Puerto Rico has not taken care of business for decades and things now are decidedly worse, especially for its economy and power grid. Consider this: Hurricanes Harvey and Irma reportedly shaved a half-percentage point off the U.S.’s economic forecast this year, based on the storms’ effects on two large states – Texas and Florida, which together account for 15 percent of the U.S. economy.

What economic havoc will Irma and María wreak on Puerto Rico, whose economy has been in negative territory for a decade? The island’s gross product reportedly declined another 1.1 percent in fiscal year 2016 in pre-inflation dollars, making for over nine years of decline.

Fiscal Oversight

The Fiscal Oversight and Management Board that rules over Puerto Rico since the beginning of 2017 has a dire mess on its hands. Not only must it steer Puerto Rico through renegotiation of $70 billion in debt (excluding another $40 billion-plus in pension liabilities), it also must find a way to reconstruct the island of 3.4 million people.

Before Hurricanes Irma and María hit, the fiscal board had been pushing layoffs affecting over 130,000 government workers, seeking to enforce via federal court. Will it proceed as planned? Very likely, Puerto Rico will need to reassign many workers to rebuild the island.

No Electricity

Without electricity, businesses cannot return to normal, striking a major blow to economic activity (down  20 points between 2005 and 2016), low labor participation rate (40 percent) and low incomes (median household income of $18,626 as of 2015).

In case you missed it, Puerto Rico Electric Authority (PREPA) bondholders, concerned about their investment, asked to place the utility into receivership before Hurricane María. A federal court denied the petition, stating that decision was up to the fiscal board.

No Insurance

In the states, insurance payouts for hurricane damages and losses help kickstart recovery, but that is unlikely to happen in Puerto Rico. Many island homes are uninsured (only 50 percent have policies against wind damage), to say nothing of flood insurance (less than 1 percent), reports the Journal.

In addition, Puerto Ricans frown upon mortgage debt, which means people own their uninsured homes, many passed down through generations. These homeowners won’t be able to rebuild without substantial financial assistance. Home foreclosures, last reported at a “stubbornly high” 7 percent, may soar.

Puerto Ricans have shown resolve in the face of catastrophe. /Government of Puerto Rico

Migration Flow

It’s too soon to say whether the twin hurricane disasters will push more peo

ple off the island toward the upper 48, including Florida. Face it, historically migration has been Puerto Rico’s relief valve. However, people currently are broke and lack resources for such a move. But they are not broken, demonstrating resolve in the face of catastrophe. Many indicate they plan to stay, according to news reports.

But if the island is not minimally up and running soon, desperation may change that.

Reinventing Puerto Rico

Paradise is not lost. As insensitive as it may sound, this island of stunning beauty has the opportunity to rethink wasteful policies and reinvent itself for a 21st century Puerto Rico, one that is responsive to, and works for, its population and not just the kleptocracy at the top.

Grasp it – hard – with both hands.

˜˜Maria Padilla, Editor

Hurricane María Galvanizes Puerto Ricans in Central Florida

Puerto Rico Gov. Ricardo Rosselló has demonstrated grace and leadership under the island’s extreme circumstances./Office of the Governor of Puerto Rico

The devastation caused by Hurricane María in Puerto Rico has galvanized the diaspora in Central Florida to  help the island.

CASA is a coalition of organizations working to send food and supplies to Puerto Rico. At the podium are Jimmy Torres-Velez and Peter Vivaldi (partially obscured). /Facebook

About 14 local and other groups have formed a coalition called CASA – Coordinadora de Apoya, Solidaridad y Ayuda – to collect basic supplies: water, batteries, disposable diapers, canned and dry foods – to send to the island of 3.4 million people ravaged by the storm. Residents are without power and cell phone services knocked out by the Category 4 hurricane, the worse to hit Puerto Rico and the entire United States in decades, according to the National Hurricane Center. It may take months to restore a sense of normality to Puerto Rico.

First Baptist

The group this week held a press conference at Acacia Network, formerly Asociación Borinqueña,  announcing its plans. Several Orlando-area locations are designated drop-off points, including First Baptist Church Orlando, where a shipping container is set up.

This is the second container to be stationed at First Baptist that is destined for Puerto Rico, an effort   initially spearheaded by Peter Vivaldi.

The first container, filled with 25,000 pounds of supplies, was prompted by Hurricane Irma and was due to arrive on the island Friday, September 22.

The response to the Puerto Rico catastrophe has been visceral, emotional – and impressive. Hurricane María tore through Puerto Rico and also tore through the hearts of its sons and daughters living in Florida and throughout the nation.

“Ver esto me emociona, YESS Ya la ayuda va para Puerto Rico 🇵🇷 yo sé que hay mucha gente preparándose para ayudar eso me llena de tranquilidad..GRACIAS DIOS,” wrote Realtor Karen Díaz de Suárez on Facebook.

Hurricane María: One of Many Disasters

Puerto Rico hasn’t caught a break for the past 10 years, and that’s putting it lightly. The island, dogged by a decade-old recession, came under the control of a congressionally-mandated fiscal board due to its inability to pay $70 billion in debt. The Fiscal Oversight and Management Board in the spring invoked a special bankruptcy for Puerto Rico, generating protests and tense negotiations with bondholders. Then came Hurricane Irma, a category 3 hurricane that knocked out 70 percent of the island’s power. While still in the throes of recovering from Irma, Hurricane Maria followed about two weeks later, capsizing the entire island. Puerto Rico lost all its electric power and cell phone communications (a small percentage has been restored).

But 5 million Puerto Ricans live in the states, 1 million in Florida alone – more than the 3.4 million who reside on the island. The diaspora is in an excellent position to lend a hand and generate relief funds.

Supplies Needed

Here are items that are needed on the island, per the office of the governor of Puerto Rico:

Bottled water

Disposable plates, cups and utensils

Soap, deodorant, toothpaste, tootbrushes

Over-the-counter medications: ibuprofen, aspirin, antibiotic cream

Bed sheets

Pajamas for men, women and children

Baby items: disposable diapers, baby wipes, baby formula


Sleeping bags, cots


Pots and pans

Canned and dry food

Dog food

Mosquito repellant

Where to Drop-off 

  •  Directly to the shipping container at First Baptist Church of Orlando, 3000 S. John Young Pkwy., 32805
  • Acacia Network (Centro Borinqueño), 1865 N. Econlockhatchee, 32817
  • Orlando Eye, 360 International Drive, 32819
  • Puerto Rico Federal Affairs Administration, 15 South Orlando Ave., Kissimmee 34741

Financial Help

Be careful to whom you donate money. The island’s First Lady Beatriz Rosselló has set up the website and is accepting donations.


Gov. Ricardo Rosselló has asked stateside Puerto Ricans not to travel to the family in a desperate attempt to find family members. But it is OK to travel to the island as part of an organization of volunteers, such as the Red Cross and others.

“I know it’s frustrating but it’s also true that the streets are dangerous and we are still operating under emergency protocols. I do not recommend it because it is a personal risk,” the governor said.

˜˜Maria Padilla, Editor

Waiting for Hurricane Irma to Hit

Gov. Rick Scott, a Navy veteran, likes to wear a Navy cap during hurricane briefings./screen shot

It’s all over but the waiting for Hurricane Irma. After the hustle of preparation, there is nothing to do but wait for the hurricane to hit Central Florida. We are now experiencing the outer bands dropping rain in the Orlando area as the hurricane makes a second landfall near Naples in southwest Florida.

Which has left me thinking, a hurricane is a lot like a political campaign – a hive of activity right before the main event, similar to campaign mode, followed by the quiet of the hurricane itself, akin to election day when there’s nothing more to do but wait till all blows over.

There are other political parallels, particularly in dress. Have you noticed there’s a uniform look that goes with the theater of hurricane watch and preparation, much as there is a campaign look, one that  is not too distracting and states, “Look at me. I’m taking care of business.” And not too delicately, “Vote for me!”

Hurricane  Irma Uniform

Gov. Rick Scott likes to sport a baseball cap with “NAVY” written across the top (he is a Navy veteran) while surrounding himself with what appear to be a bevy of National Guard officials in full uniform, which makes me wonder, don’t they have something more urgent to do? But, of course, they are lending “urgency” to the press conference itself.

Other elected officials wear polo shirts with emergency management or state/local government  insignia. Sometimes the hurricane costume involves a bomber jacket of sorts. President George W. Bush preferred this look.

Trump’s hurricane look. /White House Flickr stream

When President Donald Trump visited Texas twice, he wore a uniform of khaki pants and white polo shirt and loose navy jacket, his man-of-the-people look. Thankfully, his cap didn’t say MAGA but “USA.”

Folks criticized Melania Trump‘s six-inch heels, although she wore them on her way to Air Force One, not in Texas. A change of hurricane wardrobe involved white Adidas sneakers and a baseball cap stating “FLOTUS.” On the second visit, another cap read “TEXAS.”

And, to be fair, all presidents and first families do this.

Disaster Wear

TV reporters have a disaster look of their own: baseball caps and jackets with their station’s logo. And they do silly things like stand in the wind as it tosses them about and is about to blow them away. Or stand in floodwaters, marveling, “Look how deep the water is!”

When I lived in Nevada, it became a joke to guess which newbie reporter would land the plum assignment of standing in the middle of the season’s first snowstorm in Truckee, Calif., to earn their reporter street cred. Frozen before there was “Frozen.”

Meteorologists do their own thing, taking off their jackets but never the tie. This is a  roll-up-your-sleeves moment. Working hard here! I get it; broadcast is visual.

Read But Not Seen

Print reporters are not seen but read, although this, too, is changing, with videos and audio reporting. Still, they are not nearly as visible. But every newsroom – print and broadcast – is jolted with energy during disasters or crises.

Reporters under disaster duress. /screen shot

Reporters, editors, news producers and others are working very long, almost non-stop hours, under stressful conditions. They don’t see their families and eat mountains of junk food to stay energized. Elected officials and administrators do too.

Because woe to the governor, county mayor or mayor who doesn’t make a show of protecting and keeping their constituents safe or, at the very least, empathize as people lose their homes and, possibly, everything they own.

Show Concern

So, go ahead. Show concern and empathy. Wear the hurricane uniform. If not, you can expect to get hammered, and rightly so, as soon as everyone is high and dry.

˜˜Maria Padilla, Editor